The influence of dose uncertainty on the assessment of radiation risks of non-cancer mortality among Russian participants in the liquidation of the consequences of the accident at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant

«Radiation and Risk», 2022, vol. 31, No. 2, pp.21-35

DOI: 10.21870/0131-3878-2022-31-2-21-35

Authors

Chekin S.Yu. – Head of Lab. Contacts: 4 Korolyov str., Obninsk, Kaluga region, Russia, 249035. Tel.: (484) 399-30-79; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .
Maksioutov M.A. – Head of Dep., C. Sc., Tech.
Kashcheev V.V. – Head of Lab., C. Sc., Biol.
Karpenko S.V. – Engineer
Tumanov K.А. – Head of Lab., C. Sc., Biol.
Korelo A.M. – Sen. Researcher
Kochergina E.V. – Head of Lab., C. Sc., Med.
Zelenskaya N.S. – Researcher
Lashkova O.E. – Researcher
Shchukina N.V. – Sen. Researcher
Ivanov V.K. – Scientific Advisor of NRER, Chairman of RSCRP, Corresponding Member of RAS, D. Sc., Tech. A. Tsyb MRRC.
A. Tsyb MRRC, Obninsk

Abstract

Currently, the system of standards and rules of radiation protection considers the need to constraint the absorbed radiation doses in order to prevent the development of deterministic effects of ionizing radiation on humans. Deterministic effects in terms of mortality include bone marrow syndrome with a dose threshold of 1 Gy, gastrointestinal syndrome and pneumonitis with dose thresholds of 6 Gy. For inclusion in international radiation safety standards, a threshold of 0.5 Gy for cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases is being discussed. The wide experience of radiation-epidemiological stud-ies shows that the deterministic effects of mortality are not limited to those effects that are currently considered in the system of standards and rules of radiation protection. This paper presents esti-mates of radiation risks of mortality from diseases of the circulatory system (CSD) and the digestive system, as well as dose thresholds corresponding to these effects, in the Russian cohort of liquidators of the Chernobyl accident registered in the National Radiation and Epidemiological Register (NRER), who have registered doses from external whole-body exposure to gamma radiation within 1 Gy. The risks were estimated over the follow-up period 1986-2020. The stability of estimated radiation risks of mortality from CSD and from the digestive system diseases in relation to the uncertainty of personal doses received by liquidators has been studied. The absorbed doses received by 11% of the liquida-tors were estimated from the data of personal dosimeters, the maximum error was about 50%. For the remaining 89% of liquidators, group and route doses were registered, and the maximum uncer-tainty of individual doses was about 500%. For CSD mortality, the excess relative rates per 1 Gy (ERR/Gy) were 0.361 and 0.349, excluding and considering dose uncertainties, respectively. For mortality from diseases of the digestive system, ERR/Gy=0,791 excluding dose uncertainty and ERR/Gy=0,726 with considering dose uncertainty. Uncertainties in individual dose estimates result in 5% and 8% reductions in ERR/Gy estimates (for CSD mortality and digestive disease, respec-tively). This reduction in risk estimates is not related to a bias in the dose estimates. It is caused by the statistical properties of radiation risk models in conventional radiation epidemiology. If the excessive mortality from the studied causes is attributed to deterministic effects, then the estimates of the corresponding dose thresholds, considering the uncertainty of individual doses, also increase quite slightly: for CSD – from 0,028 Gy to 0,029 Gy, and for diseases of the digestive system – from 0,013 Gy to 0,014 Gy. The obtained results confirm the high stability and validity of radiation risk assess-ments of non-oncological diseases obtained earlier from the doses of Russian participants in the liquidation of the consequences of the Chernobyl accident registered in the unified federal database of the NRER.

Key words
radiation risk, excessive relative rate, liquidators of the Chernobyl accident, external gamma radiation, absorbed dose, mortality, diseases of the circulatory system, diseases of the digestive system, deterministic effect, dose threshold, dose uncertainty, radiation risk assessment bias, dose threshold assessment bias.

References

1. Radiation Safety Standards (RSS-99/2009). Sanitary-epidemiological rules and standards. Moscow, Federal Center of Hygiene and Epidemiology of Rospotrebnadzor, 2009. 100 p. (In Russian).

2. ICRP, 2007. The 2007 Recommendations of the International Commission on Radiological Protection. ICRP Publication 103. Ann. ICRP, 2007, vol. 37, no. 2-4, pp. 1-332.

3. ICRP, 2012. ICRP statement on tissue reactions and early and late effects of radiation in normal tissues and organs – threshold doses for tissue reactions in a radiation protection context. ICRP Publication 118. Ann. ICRP, vol. 41, no. 1-2, pp. 1-326.

4. Jablon S., Ishida M., Beebe G.W. Studies of the mortality of A-bomb survivors. 2. Mortality in selections I and II, 1950-1959. Radiat. Res., 1964, vol. 21, pp. 423-445.

5. Shimizu Y., Kato H., Schull W. J., Hoel D.G. Studies of the mortality of A-bomb survivors. 9. Mortality, 1950-1985: Part 3. Noncancer mortality based on the revised doses (DS86). Radiat. Res., 1992, vol. 130, no. 2, pp. 249-266.

6. United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR). Effects of ionizing radiation. UNSCEAR 2006 Report to the General Assembly with Scientific Annexes. Vol. I. New York, United Nations, 2008. 383 p.

7. Ivanov V.K., Maksioutov M.A., Tumanov K.A., Kochergina E.V., Vlasov O.K., Chekin S.Yu., Gorski A.I., Korelo A.M., Shchukina N.V., Zelenskaya N.S., Lashkova O.E., Ivanov S.A., Kaprin A.D. 35-year experi-ence in the functioning of the National Radiation and Epidemiological Registry as a State information system for monitoring the radiological consequences of the Chernobyl accident. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 2021, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 7-39. (In Russian).

8. Medical radiological consequences of Chernobyl: forecast and actual data after 30 years. Eds.: Corr. Member RAS V.K. Ivanov, Corr. Member RAS A.D. Kaprin. Moscow, GEOS, 2015. 450 p. (In Russian).

9. Ozasa K., Shimizu Y., Suyama A., Kasagi F., Soda M., Grant E.J., Sakata R., Sugiyama H., Kodama K. Studies of the mortality of atomic bomb survivors, Report 14, 1950-2003: an overview of cancer and noncancer diseases. Radiat. Res., 2012, vol. 177, no. 3, pp. 229-243.

10. Ivanov V.K., Maksioutov M.A., Chekin S.Yu., Petrov A.V., Biryukov A.P., Kruglova Z.G., Matyash V.A., Tsyb A.F., Manton K.G., Kravchenko J.S. The risk of radiation-induced cerebrovascular disease in Chernobyl emergency workers. Health Phys., 2006, vol. 90, no. 3, pp. 199-207.

11. Ivanov V.K., Chekin S.Yu., Kashcheev V.V., Maksioutov M.A., Tumanov K.A., Tsyb A.F. Mortality of the Chernobyl emergency workers: dose dependences and groups of the potential risk. Radiatsionnaya biologiya. Radioekologiya – Radiation Biology. Radioekology, 2011, vol. 51, no. 1, pp. 41-48. (In Russian).

12. Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Kashcheev V.V., Karpenko S.V., Tumanov K.A., Kochergina E.V., Zelenskaya N.S., Lashkova O.E. Estimating of radiation risks of non-cancer diseases among Russian Chernobyl cleanup workers. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 2021, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 78-93. (In Russian).

13. Pitkevich V.A., Ivanov V.K., Tsyb A.F., Maksyutov M.A., Matyash V.A., Shchukina N.V. Dosimetric data of the All-Russia Medical and Dosimetric State Registry for emergency workers. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 1995, special issue 2, pp. 3-44. (In Russian).

14. United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR). UNSCEAR 2012 Report to the General Assembly, with scientific annexes. Scientific Annexes. New York, United Nations, 2015. 232 p.

15. Breslow N., Day N. Statistical methods in cancer research. Vol. II. The design and analysis of cohort studies. IARC Scientific Publication No. 82. Lyon, IARC, 1987. 406 p.

16. International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health, 10th revision (ICD-10). Vol. 1 (Part 1). Geneva, WHO, 1995. 698 p. (In Russian).

17. Stram D.O., Kopecky K.J. Power and uncertainty analysis of epidemiological studies of radiation-related disease risk in which dose estimates are based on a complex dosimetry system: some observations. Radiat. Res., 2003, vol. 160, no. 4, pp. 408-417.

18. Wu Y., Hoffman F.O., Apostoaei A.I., Kwon D., Thomas B.A., Glass R., Zablotska L.B. Methods to account for uncertainties in exposure assessment in studies of environmental exposures. Environ. Health, 2019, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 31.

19. Stayner L., Vrijheid M., Cardis E., Stram D.O., Deltour I., Gilbert S.J., Howe G. A Monte Carlo maximum likelihood method for estimating uncertainty arising from shared errors in exposures in epidemiological studies of nuclear workers. Radiat. Res., 2007, vol. 168, no. 3, pp. 757-763.

20. Breslow N.E. Discussion of the paper by D.R. Cox. J. R. Statist. Soc. B, 1972, vol. 34, pp. 216-217.

21. Lyn D.Y. On the Breslow estimator. Lifetime Data Anal., 2007, vol. 13, pp. 471-480.

22. Breslow N., Day N. Statistical methods in cancer research. Vol. I. The analysis of case-control studies. IARC Scientific Publication No. 32. Lyon, IARC, 1980. 350 p.

23. Pierce D.A., Vaeth M., Cologne J.B. Allowance for random dose estimation errors in atomic bomb survivor studies: a revision. Radiat. Res., 2008, vol. 170, no. 1, pp. 118-126.

24. Gorsky А.I., Maksioutov М.А., Tumanov K.A., Shchukina N.V., Chekin S.Yu., Ivanov V.K. Non-parametric analysis of radiation risks of mortality among the liquidators of the consequences of the Chernobyl accident. Radiatsionnaya biologiya. Radioekologiya – Radiation Biology. Radioekology, 2016, vol. 56, no. 2, pp. 138-148.

25. Kashcheev V.V., Chekin S.Yu., Karpenko S.V., Maksioutov M.A., Menyaylo A.N., Tumanov K.A., Kochergina E.V., Kashcheeva P.V., Gorsky A.I., Shchukina N.V., Lovachev S.S., Vlasov O.K., Ivanov V.K. Radiation risk of cardiovascular diseases in the cohort of Russian emergency workers of the Chernobyl accident. Health Phys., 2017, vol. 113, no. 1, pp. 23-29.

26. Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Kashcheev V.V., Tumanov K.A., Korelo A.M., Kochergina E.V., Vlasov O.K., Shchukina N.V., Karpenko S.V., Lovachev S.S., Ivanov V.K. Identification of group of radiation risk on mortality from diseases of circulatory system among Russian recovery operation workers of the Chernobyl accident. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 2016, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 24-34. (In Russian).

Full-text article (in Russian)